{ "created_utc": "2026-09-14T08:44:14.062806+00:00", "reference": "SPGRN2020 full wavefield (max_slowness=0)", "method": "Linear interpolation to 1 s on all five backends' common valid origin-time interval at each distance through 500 s", "fitted_time_shifts": false, "fitted_amplitude_factors": false, "relative_l2_definition": "norm(values-reference)/norm(reference), over ENU and time for each distance", "correlation_definition": "Pearson correlation; null when either demeaned trace has zero norm", "components": [ "E", "N", "U" ], "unit": "m", "comparison_time_ranges_s": [ [ 3.0, 500.0 ], [ 40.0, 500.0 ], [ 78.0, 500.0 ] ], "provenance": { "qseis06": { "npz_path": "C:\\Users\\zjc\\python_works\\pygrnwang\\examples\\output\\qseis06-regional-shared-stf\\disp.npz", "npz_sha256": "721ef7bf98e8bd26020c87c4f08d81616b7bbcd14a0dd122223005bb71cef3e6", "summary_path": "C:\\Users\\zjc\\python_works\\pygrnwang\\examples\\output\\qseis06-regional-shared-stf\\summary.json", "summary": { "backend": "QSEIS06", "started_utc": "2026-09-14T08:39:10Z", "platform": "Windows-11-10.0.26200-SP0", "python": "3.12.13", "dependencies": { "numpy": "2.3.5", "scipy": "1.18.0", "pandas": "3.0.0", "matplotlib": "3.11.0", "obspy": "1.5.0" }, "source_depth_km": 10.0, "receiver_depth_km": 0.0, "moment_nm": 1000000000000000.0, "strike_dip_rake_deg": [ 30.0, 45.0, 90.0 ], "azimuth_deg": 30.0, "reuse": false, "model": "Bundled AK135 elastic properties; illustrative constant Qp=600, Qs=300", "outputs": { "disp": { "shape": [ 3, 3, 256 ], "components": [ "E", "N", "U" ], "unit": "m", "finite": true, "peak_absolute": 1.3862526806476928e-08 } }, "sampling_interval_s": 4.0, "time_window_s": 4092.0, "distances_km": [ 300.0, 600.0, 900.0 ], "output_time_range_s": [ 0.0, 1020.0 ], "native_samples": 1024, "earth_model_numeric_rows": 24, "wavelet_type": 0, "wavelet_duration_samples": 16, "wavelet_duration_s": 64.0, "flat_earth_transform": true, "regional": true, "source_time_function": { "scheme_id": "normalized_sin_squared_64s_damping_compensated_v1", "duration_s": 64.0, "samples": 1024, "sample_spacing_s": 0.06256109481915934, "wavelet_type": 0, "wavelet_duration_samples": 16, "sampling_interval_s": 4.0, "native_time_window_s": 4092.0, "anti_alias": 0.01, "fi_hz": -0.00017911427147591097, "rate_unit": "1/s", "time_unit": "s", "physical_definition": "r(t) = 2/64 * sin(pi*t/64)^2 for 0 <= t <= 64 s; zero otherwise", "input_definition": "piecewise-linear samples of r(t) * exp(2*pi*fi*t); no input-area renormalization", "effective_definition": "piecewise-linear input(t) * exp(-2*pi*fi*t)", "target_rate_integral": 1.0, "input_rate_integral": 0.9647094485300882, "effective_rate_integral": 1.0000000004130927, "target_centroid_s": 32.0, "effective_centroid_s": 32.00000073412074, "effective_rate_relative_l2": 1.9884466105608343e-06, "spectral_relative_l2_0_to_0_0625_hz": 1.7577432851302247e-06, "spectral_max_absolute_error_0_to_0_0625_hz": 1.5646882209943217e-06, "physical_validation_limits": { "area_absolute_error": 1e-08, "centroid_absolute_error_s": 1e-05, "rate_relative_l2": 1e-05, "spectral_relative_l2": 1e-05 }, "reader_instruction": "Read velo/strain_rate/stress_rate; integrate once with cumsum(rate)*4 s in the example", "input_relative_path": "10.00/0.00/0_0/grn.inp", "input_original_sha256": "73e1996946b763bb449c2bd2040a1c0210bbbe0d95494d85bc7d2c3ae8c41373", "input_prepared_sha256": "cc84f2af0babb4c819a33036fd76746df67ccccf0561b7020092f50d7d77da0c", "samples_relative_path": "../source_time_function.npz", "description_relative_path": "../source_time_function.json", "samples_sha256": "338b4f06ebd8d08487d654680d42ec451effbace3de55d48a38a3a3d4a38c7c3" }, "elapsed_seconds": 242.44, "file_count": 31, "output_bytes": 1240827 }, "native_time_ranges_s": [ [ 0.0, 1020.0 ], [ 0.0, 1020.0 ], [ 0.0, 1020.0 ] ], "library_metadata_path": "C:\\Users\\zjc\\python_works\\pygrnwang\\examples\\output\\qseis06-regional-shared-stf\\library\\green_lib_info.json", "library_metadata": { "processes_num": 1, "event_depth_list": [ 10.0 ], "receiver_depth_list": [ 0.0 ], "grn_dist_range": [ 300.0, 900.0 ], "grn_delta_dist": 300.0, "N_dist": 3, "N_dist_group": 1, "N_each_group": 3, "time_window": 4092.0, "sampling_interval": 4.0, "sampling_num": 1024, "slowness_int_algorithm": 0, "slowness_window": null, "time_reduction_velo": 0, "wavenumber_sampling_rate": 12, "anti_alias": 0.01, "free_surface": true, "wavelet_duration": 16, "wavelet_type": 0, "flat_earth_transform": true, "path_nd": "C:\\Users\\zjc\\python_works\\pygrnwang\\examples\\output\\qseis06-regional-shared-stf\\ak135_tutorial.nd", "path_nd_without_Q": "C:\\Users\\zjc\\python_works\\pygrnwang\\examples\\output\\qseis06-regional-shared-stf\\library\\noQ.nd", "earth_model_layer_num": 24 } }, "qseis2025": { "npz_path": "C:\\Users\\zjc\\python_works\\pygrnwang\\examples\\output\\qseis2025-regional-shared-stf\\disp.npz", "npz_sha256": "721ef7bf98e8bd26020c87c4f08d81616b7bbcd14a0dd122223005bb71cef3e6", "summary_path": "C:\\Users\\zjc\\python_works\\pygrnwang\\examples\\output\\qseis2025-regional-shared-stf\\summary.json", "summary": { "backend": "QSEIS2025", "started_utc": "2026-09-14T08:39:20Z", "platform": "Windows-11-10.0.26200-SP0", "python": "3.12.13", "dependencies": { "numpy": "2.3.5", "scipy": "1.18.0", "pandas": "3.0.0", "matplotlib": "3.11.0", "obspy": "1.5.0" }, "source_depth_km": 10.0, "receiver_depth_km": 0.0, "moment_nm": 1000000000000000.0, "strike_dip_rake_deg": [ 30.0, 45.0, 90.0 ], "azimuth_deg": 30.0, "reuse": false, "model": "Bundled AK135 elastic properties; illustrative constant Qp=600, Qs=300", "outputs": { "disp": { "shape": [ 3, 3, 256 ], "components": [ "E", "N", "U" ], "unit": "m", "finite": true, "peak_absolute": 1.3862526806476928e-08 }, "strain": { "shape": [ 3, 6, 256 ], "components": [ "EE", "EN", "EU", "NN", "NU", "UU" ], "unit": "1", "finite": true, "peak_absolute": 2.0537011131837202e-13 }, "stress": { "shape": [ 3, 6, 256 ], "components": [ "EE", "EN", "EU", "NN", "NU", "UU" ], "unit": "Pa", "finite": true, "peak_absolute": 0.01279058879999433 } }, "sampling_interval_s": 4.0, "time_window_s": 4092.0, "output_time_range_s": [ 0.0, 1020.0 ], "distances_km": [ 300.0, 600.0, 900.0 ], "native_samples": 1024, "earth_model_numeric_rows": 24, "wavelet_type": 0, "wavelet_duration_samples": 16, "wavelet_duration_s": 64.0, "flat_earth_transform": true, "regional": true, "source_time_function": { "scheme_id": "normalized_sin_squared_64s_damping_compensated_v1", "duration_s": 64.0, "samples": 1024, "sample_spacing_s": 0.06256109481915934, "wavelet_type": 0, "wavelet_duration_samples": 16, "sampling_interval_s": 4.0, "native_time_window_s": 4092.0, "anti_alias": 0.01, "fi_hz": -0.00017911427147591097, "rate_unit": "1/s", "time_unit": "s", "physical_definition": "r(t) = 2/64 * sin(pi*t/64)^2 for 0 <= t <= 64 s; zero otherwise", "input_definition": "piecewise-linear samples of r(t) * exp(2*pi*fi*t); no input-area renormalization", "effective_definition": "piecewise-linear input(t) * exp(-2*pi*fi*t)", "target_rate_integral": 1.0, "input_rate_integral": 0.9647094485300882, "effective_rate_integral": 1.0000000004130927, "target_centroid_s": 32.0, "effective_centroid_s": 32.00000073412074, "effective_rate_relative_l2": 1.9884466105608343e-06, "spectral_relative_l2_0_to_0_0625_hz": 1.7577432851302247e-06, "spectral_max_absolute_error_0_to_0_0625_hz": 1.5646882209943217e-06, "physical_validation_limits": { "area_absolute_error": 1e-08, "centroid_absolute_error_s": 1e-05, "rate_relative_l2": 1e-05, "spectral_relative_l2": 1e-05 }, "reader_instruction": "Read velo/strain_rate/stress_rate; integrate once with cumsum(rate)*4 s in the example", "input_relative_path": "10.00/0.00/0_0/grn.inp", "input_original_sha256": "60e1d673030b4beb47f564b8e358adcdd76da148a029446ffeca44e1d03c5b5e", "input_prepared_sha256": "fc95e2e799e808f0afc7f2822ca7824d12254c3ee4e6a55df2a7998db661b5f1", "samples_relative_path": "../source_time_function.npz", "description_relative_path": "../source_time_function.json", "samples_sha256": "338b4f06ebd8d08487d654680d42ec451effbace3de55d48a38a3a3d4a38c7c3" }, "elapsed_seconds": 248.391, "file_count": 83, "output_bytes": 3833713 }, "native_time_ranges_s": [ [ 0.0, 1020.0 ], [ 0.0, 1020.0 ], [ 0.0, 1020.0 ] ], "library_metadata_path": "C:\\Users\\zjc\\python_works\\pygrnwang\\examples\\output\\qseis2025-regional-shared-stf\\library\\green_lib_info.json", "library_metadata": { "processes_num": 1, "event_depth_list": [ 10.0 ], "receiver_depth_list": [ 0.0 ], "grn_dist_range": [ 300.0, 900.0 ], "grn_delta_dist": 300.0, "N_dist": 3, "N_dist_group": 1, "N_each_group": 3, "time_window": 4092.0, "sampling_interval": 4.0, "sampling_num": 1024, "slowness_int_algorithm": 0, "slowness_window": null, "time_reduction_velo": 0, "wavenumber_sampling_rate": 12, "anti_alias": 0.01, "free_surface": 0, "wavelet_duration": 16, "wavelet_type": 0, "flat_earth_transform": true, "path_nd": "C:\\Users\\zjc\\python_works\\pygrnwang\\examples\\output\\qseis2025-regional-shared-stf\\ak135_tutorial.nd", "path_nd_without_Q": "C:\\Users\\zjc\\python_works\\pygrnwang\\examples\\output\\qseis2025-regional-shared-stf\\library\\noQ.nd", "earth_model_layer_num": 24 } }, "spgrn2012": { "npz_path": "C:\\Users\\zjc\\python_works\\pygrnwang\\examples\\output\\spgrn2012\\disp.npz", "npz_sha256": "a8f8cfe6c893a3dfa66bf3a98fb19ff9286eff799a529096e55b469d37ba4fc7", "summary_path": "C:\\Users\\zjc\\python_works\\pygrnwang\\examples\\output\\spgrn2012\\summary-reuse.json", "summary": { "backend": "SPGRN2012", "started_utc": "2026-09-14T02:37:36Z", "platform": "Windows-11-10.0.26200-SP0", "python": "3.12.13", "dependencies": { "numpy": "2.3.5", "scipy": "1.18.0", "pandas": "3.0.0", "matplotlib": "3.11.0", "obspy": "1.5.0" }, "source_depth_km": 10.0, "receiver_depth_km": 0.0, "moment_nm": 1000000000000000.0, "strike_dip_rake_deg": [ 30.0, 45.0, 90.0 ], "azimuth_deg": 30.0, "reuse": true, "model": "Bundled AK135 elastic properties; illustrative constant Qp=600, Qs=300", "outputs": { "disp": { "shape": [ 3, 3, 256 ], "components": [ "E", "N", "U" ], "unit": "m", "finite": true, "peak_absolute": 1.5146271724570058e-08 } }, "sampling_interval_s": 4.0, "time_window_s": 1020.0, "distances_km": [ 300.0, 600.0, 900.0 ], "spec_time_window_s": 4092.0, "max_frequency_hz": 0.0625, "t0_s": -40.0, "v0_km_s": 10.0, "source_duration_s": 64.0, "elapsed_seconds": 0.115, "file_count": 15, "output_bytes": 13154039 }, "native_time_ranges_s": [ [ -10.0, 1010.0 ], [ 20.0, 1040.0 ], [ 50.0, 1070.0 ] ], "library_metadata_path": "C:\\Users\\zjc\\python_works\\pygrnwang\\examples\\output\\spgrn2012\\library\\green_lib_info.json", "library_metadata": { "processes_num": 1, "path_green": "C:\\Users\\zjc\\python_works\\pygrnwang\\examples\\output\\spgrn2012\\library", "event_depth_list": [ 10.0 ], "receiver_depth_list": [ 0.0 ], "spec_time_window": 4092.0, "sampling_interval": 4.0, "max_frequency": 0.0625, "max_slowness": 0.3, "anti_alias": 0.01, "gravity_fc": 0.0, "gravity_harmonic": 0, "cal_sph": 1, "cal_tor": 1, "source_radius": 0.0, "cal_gf": 1, "time_window": 1020.0, "t0": -40.0, "v0": 10.0, "source_duration": 64.0, "dist_range": [ 300.0, 900.0 ], "delta_dist_range": [ 300.0, 300.0 ], "path_nd": "C:\\Users\\zjc\\python_works\\pygrnwang\\examples\\output\\spgrn2012\\ak135_tutorial.nd", "earth_model_layer_num": null, "physical_dispersion": 0, "path_nd_without_Q": "C:\\Users\\zjc\\python_works\\pygrnwang\\examples\\output\\spgrn2012\\library\\noQ.nd", "dist_list": [ 300.0, 600.0, 900.0 ], "samples_num": 256 } }, "spgrn2020": { "npz_path": "C:\\Users\\zjc\\python_works\\pygrnwang\\examples\\output\\spgrn2020-converged\\disp.npz", "npz_sha256": "a47b399ab45892abdcba5ec0237c0ba3a6bea035a8eb5c3f7c21884ac8a77401", "summary_path": "C:\\Users\\zjc\\python_works\\pygrnwang\\examples\\output\\spgrn2020-converged\\summary.json", "summary": { "backend": "SPGRN2020", "started_utc": "2026-09-14T08:17:58Z", "platform": "Windows-11-10.0.26200-SP0", "python": "3.12.13", "dependencies": { "numpy": "2.3.5", "scipy": "1.18.0", "pandas": "3.0.0", "matplotlib": "3.11.0", "obspy": "1.5.0" }, "source_depth_km": 10.0, "receiver_depth_km": 0.0, "moment_nm": 1000000000000000.0, "strike_dip_rake_deg": [ 30.0, 45.0, 90.0 ], "azimuth_deg": 30.0, "reuse": false, "model": "Bundled AK135 elastic properties; illustrative constant Qp=600, Qs=300", "outputs": { "disp": { "shape": [ 3, 3, 256 ], "components": [ "E", "N", "U" ], "unit": "m", "finite": true, "peak_absolute": 1.4550723940949578e-08 } }, "sampling_interval_s": 4.0, "time_window_s": 1020.0, "distances_km": [ 300.0, 600.0, 900.0 ], "spec_time_window_s": 4092.0, "max_frequency_hz": 0.0625, "green_before_p_s": 40.0, "source_duration_s": 64.0, "max_slowness_s_km": 0.0, "full_wavefield": true, "trace_start_times_s": [ 3.0, 40.0, 78.0 ], "elapsed_seconds": 17.141, "file_count": 15, "output_bytes": 121654111 }, "native_time_ranges_s": [ [ 3.0, 1023.0 ], [ 40.0, 1060.0 ], [ 78.0, 1098.0 ] ], "library_metadata_path": "C:\\Users\\zjc\\python_works\\pygrnwang\\examples\\output\\spgrn2020-converged\\library\\green_lib_info.json", "library_metadata": { "processes_num": 1, "path_green": "C:\\Users\\zjc\\python_works\\pygrnwang\\examples\\output\\spgrn2020-converged\\library", "event_depth_list": [ 10.0 ], "receiver_depth_list": [ 0.0 ], "spec_time_window": 4092.0, "sampling_interval": 4.0, "max_frequency": 0.0625, "max_slowness": 0.0, "anti_alias": 0.01, "gravity_fc": 0.0, "gravity_harmonic": 0, "cal_sph": 1, "cal_tor": 1, "source_radius": 0.0, "cal_gf": 1, "time_window": 1020.0, "green_before_p": 40.0, "source_duration": 64.0, "dist_range": [ 300.0, 900.0 ], "delta_dist_range": [ 300.0, 300.0 ], "path_nd": "C:\\Users\\zjc\\python_works\\pygrnwang\\examples\\output\\spgrn2020-converged\\ak135_tutorial.nd", "earth_model_layer_num": null, "physical_dispersion": 0, "path_nd_without_Q": "C:\\Users\\zjc\\python_works\\pygrnwang\\examples\\output\\spgrn2020-converged\\library\\noQ.nd", "dist_list": [ 300.0, 600.0, 900.0 ], "samples_num": 256 } }, "qssp2020": { "npz_path": "C:\\Users\\zjc\\python_works\\pygrnwang\\examples\\output\\qssp2020-converged\\disp.npz", "npz_sha256": "13d692c5c1d8b4026b5532e134b07c3fa390699e7c65974e0c97f74a08301640", "summary_path": "C:\\Users\\zjc\\python_works\\pygrnwang\\examples\\output\\qssp2020-converged\\summary.json", "summary": { "backend": "QSSP2020", "started_utc": "2026-09-14T08:18:19Z", "platform": "Windows-11-10.0.26200-SP0", "python": "3.12.13", "dependencies": { "numpy": "2.3.5", "scipy": "1.18.0", "pandas": "3.0.0", "matplotlib": "3.11.0", "obspy": "1.5.0" }, "source_depth_km": 10.0, "receiver_depth_km": 0.0, "moment_nm": 1000000000000000.0, "strike_dip_rake_deg": [ 30.0, 45.0, 90.0 ], "azimuth_deg": 30.0, "reuse": false, "model": "Bundled AK135 elastic properties; illustrative constant Qp=600, Qs=300", "outputs": { "disp": { "shape": [ 3, 3, 256 ], "components": [ "E", "N", "U" ], "unit": "m", "finite": true, "peak_absolute": 1.4524259876250708e-08 } }, "sampling_interval_s": 4.0, "time_window_s": 1020.0, "distances_km": [ 300.0, 600.0, 900.0 ], "spec_time_window_s": 4092.0, "max_frequency_hz": 0.0625, "harmonic_bounds": [ 2000, 8000 ], "source_duration_s": 64.0, "elapsed_seconds": 38.182, "file_count": 67, "output_bytes": 346693604 }, "native_time_ranges_s": [ [ 0.0, 1020.0 ], [ 0.0, 1020.0 ], [ 0.0, 1020.0 ] ], "library_metadata_path": "C:\\Users\\zjc\\python_works\\pygrnwang\\examples\\output\\qssp2020-converged\\library\\green_lib_info.json", "library_metadata": { "processes_num": 1, "event_depth_list": [ 10.0 ], "receiver_depth_list": [ 0.0 ], "spec_time_window": 4092.0, "sampling_interval": 4.0, "max_frequency": 0.0625, "max_slowness": 0.3, "anti_alias": 0.01, "turning_point_filter": 0, "turning_point_d1": 0.0, "turning_point_d2": 6371.0, "free_surface_filter": 1, "gravity_fc": 0.0, "gravity_harmonic": 0, "cal_sph": 1, "cal_tor": 1, "min_harmonic": 2000, "max_harmonic": 8000, "source_radius": 0.0, "source_duration": 64.0, "output_observables": [ 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "time_window": 1020.0, "sampling_num": 256, "time_reduction": 0.0, "grn_dist_range": [ 300.0, 900.0 ], "grn_delta_dist": 300.0, "path_nd": "C:\\Users\\zjc\\python_works\\pygrnwang\\examples\\output\\qssp2020-converged\\ak135_tutorial.nd", "path_nd_without_Q": "C:\\Users\\zjc\\python_works\\pygrnwang\\examples\\output\\qssp2020-converged\\library\\noQ.nd", "earth_model_layer_num": null, "physical_dispersion": 0 } } }, "limitations": [ "QSEIS uses a transformed finite-depth model over a half-space; spherical examples use the complete Earth model.", "QSEIS uses a damping-compensated custom 64 s sin-squared rate matching the SPGRN2020/QSSP physical source to the recorded interpolation tolerance.", "SPGRN2012 retains its legacy real-frequency source; displacement integration windows still differ between backends.", "QSEIS Nyquist frequency is 0.125 Hz; spherical examples use a 0.0625 Hz spectral cutoff.", "Displacement integration baselines and native time windows differ between backends.", "Thresholds check these tutorial settings; they do not establish general backend equivalence." ], "distances": [ { "distance_km": 300.0, "backends": { "qseis06": { "relative_l2": 0.1268393762564497, "correlation": 0.9978012347506638, "peak_absolute_m": 1.3862526806476928e-08, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 1.4550723940949578e-08, "absolute_peak_time_s": 120.0, "components": { "E": { "relative_l2": 0.21142254076778422, "correlation": 0.9954862113979258, "peak_absolute_m": 4.718671664468096e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 5.495577975110608e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 88.0 }, "N": { "relative_l2": 0.2114225407677834, "correlation": 0.9954862113979263, "peak_absolute_m": 8.172979067094345e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 9.518620269848064e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 88.0 }, "U": { "relative_l2": 0.07290936602598422, "correlation": 0.9972913454516318, "peak_absolute_m": 1.3862526806476928e-08, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 1.4550723940949578e-08, "absolute_peak_time_s": 120.0 } } }, "qseis2025": { "relative_l2": 0.1268393762564497, "correlation": 0.9978012347506638, "peak_absolute_m": 1.3862526806476928e-08, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 1.4550723940949578e-08, "absolute_peak_time_s": 120.0, "components": { "E": { "relative_l2": 0.21142254076778422, "correlation": 0.9954862113979258, "peak_absolute_m": 4.718671664468096e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 5.495577975110608e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 88.0 }, "N": { "relative_l2": 0.2114225407677834, "correlation": 0.9954862113979263, "peak_absolute_m": 8.172979067094345e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 9.518620269848064e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 88.0 }, "U": { "relative_l2": 0.07290936602598422, "correlation": 0.9972913454516318, "peak_absolute_m": 1.3862526806476928e-08, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 1.4550723940949578e-08, "absolute_peak_time_s": 120.0 } } }, "spgrn2012": { "relative_l2": 0.04077854551158646, "correlation": 0.9998167245155266, "peak_absolute_m": 1.5146271724570058e-08, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 1.4550723940949578e-08, "absolute_peak_time_s": 118.0, "components": { "E": { "relative_l2": 0.046874273400568336, "correlation": 0.9995318198496341, "peak_absolute_m": 5.715480041921498e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 5.495577975110608e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 90.0 }, "N": { "relative_l2": 0.04687427340056908, "correlation": 0.9995318198496342, "peak_absolute_m": 9.899501822253934e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 9.518620269848064e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 90.0 }, "U": { "relative_l2": 0.038232409076538854, "correlation": 0.9997277121845646, "peak_absolute_m": 1.5146271724570058e-08, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 1.4550723940949578e-08, "absolute_peak_time_s": 118.0 } } }, "spgrn2020": { "relative_l2": 0.0, "correlation": 1.0, "peak_absolute_m": 1.4550723940949578e-08, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 1.4550723940949578e-08, "absolute_peak_time_s": 119.0, "components": { "E": { "relative_l2": 0.0, "correlation": 1.0, "peak_absolute_m": 5.495577975110608e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 5.495577975110608e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 91.0 }, "N": { "relative_l2": 0.0, "correlation": 1.0, "peak_absolute_m": 9.518620269848064e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 9.518620269848064e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 91.0 }, "U": { "relative_l2": 0.0, "correlation": 1.0, "peak_absolute_m": 1.4550723940949578e-08, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 1.4550723940949578e-08, "absolute_peak_time_s": 119.0 } } }, "qssp2020": { "relative_l2": 0.008892090245270245, "correlation": 0.9999623038742104, "peak_absolute_m": 1.4524259876250708e-08, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 1.4550723940949578e-08, "absolute_peak_time_s": 120.0, "components": { "E": { "relative_l2": 0.012391228095774287, "correlation": 0.9998894963800711, "peak_absolute_m": 5.484154019687877e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 5.495577975110608e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 92.0 }, "N": { "relative_l2": 0.012391267120908246, "correlation": 0.999889496380071, "peak_absolute_m": 9.498831331255596e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 9.518620269848064e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 92.0 }, "U": { "relative_l2": 0.007143458684612871, "correlation": 0.9999514771119223, "peak_absolute_m": 1.4524259876250708e-08, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 1.4550723940949578e-08, "absolute_peak_time_s": 120.0 } } } } }, { "distance_km": 600.0, "backends": { "qseis06": { "relative_l2": 0.1974797064672438, "correlation": 0.9934737165638886, "peak_absolute_m": 6.3218135045597715e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 6.93153850366e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 200.0, "components": { "E": { "relative_l2": 0.21246720228848262, "correlation": 0.9943367813808205, "peak_absolute_m": 3.34960463084013e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 4.001925620986357e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 144.0 }, "N": { "relative_l2": 0.2124672022884821, "correlation": 0.9943367813808203, "peak_absolute_m": 5.801685405883101e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 6.93153850366e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 144.0 }, "U": { "relative_l2": 0.17183505439741018, "correlation": 0.9912994011564045, "peak_absolute_m": 6.3218135045597715e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 6.662565862069205e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 200.0 } } }, "qseis2025": { "relative_l2": 0.1974797064672438, "correlation": 0.9934737165638886, "peak_absolute_m": 6.3218135045597715e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 6.93153850366e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 200.0, "components": { "E": { "relative_l2": 0.21246720228848262, "correlation": 0.9943367813808205, "peak_absolute_m": 3.34960463084013e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 4.001925620986357e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 144.0 }, "N": { "relative_l2": 0.2124672022884821, "correlation": 0.9943367813808203, "peak_absolute_m": 5.801685405883101e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 6.93153850366e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 144.0 }, "U": { "relative_l2": 0.17183505439741018, "correlation": 0.9912994011564045, "peak_absolute_m": 6.3218135045597715e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 6.662565862069205e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 200.0 } } }, "spgrn2012": { "relative_l2": 0.044033959204149625, "correlation": 0.9997214724717407, "peak_absolute_m": 7.1943740780285575e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 6.93153850366e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 148.0, "components": { "E": { "relative_l2": 0.04184493373354468, "correlation": 0.9997794410704498, "peak_absolute_m": 4.153673810600653e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 4.001925620986357e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 148.0 }, "N": { "relative_l2": 0.0418449337335447, "correlation": 0.9997794410704494, "peak_absolute_m": 7.1943740780285575e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 6.93153850366e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 148.0 }, "U": { "relative_l2": 0.04720988582957243, "correlation": 0.999565270338363, "peak_absolute_m": 6.871542484705506e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 6.662565862069205e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 200.0 } } }, "spgrn2020": { "relative_l2": 0.0, "correlation": 1.0, "peak_absolute_m": 6.93153850366e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 6.93153850366e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 148.0, "components": { "E": { "relative_l2": 0.0, "correlation": 1.0, "peak_absolute_m": 4.001925620986357e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 4.001925620986357e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 148.0 }, "N": { "relative_l2": 0.0, "correlation": 0.9999999999999999, "peak_absolute_m": 6.93153850366e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 6.93153850366e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 148.0 }, "U": { "relative_l2": 0.0, "correlation": 1.0, "peak_absolute_m": 6.662565862069205e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 6.662565862069205e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 200.0 } } }, "qssp2020": { "relative_l2": 0.0037799442529229473, "correlation": 0.9999930832610049, "peak_absolute_m": 6.937699181944314e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 6.93153850366e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 148.0, "components": { "E": { "relative_l2": 0.0033555234622926785, "correlation": 0.9999931321167354, "peak_absolute_m": 4.0054819917809e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 4.001925620986357e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 148.0 }, "N": { "relative_l2": 0.003354772704310088, "correlation": 0.9999931351645194, "peak_absolute_m": 6.937699181944314e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 6.93153850366e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 148.0 }, "U": { "relative_l2": 0.004354546117630538, "correlation": 0.9999922685345858, "peak_absolute_m": 6.650376490558351e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 6.662565862069205e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 200.0 } } } } }, { "distance_km": 900.0, "backends": { "qseis06": { "relative_l2": 0.22951382655472283, "correlation": 0.9897023617946057, "peak_absolute_m": 4.032786470521637e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 4.718896012314888e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 276.0, "components": { "E": { "relative_l2": 0.23325738523935233, "correlation": 0.9912922196061632, "peak_absolute_m": 1.8688967424193267e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 1.982428249685609e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 256.0 }, "N": { "relative_l2": 0.23325738523935324, "correlation": 0.9912922196061632, "peak_absolute_m": 3.23702411197024e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 3.433666450815314e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 256.0 }, "U": { "relative_l2": 0.2233134153054795, "correlation": 0.9871619471661072, "peak_absolute_m": 4.032786470521637e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 4.718896012314888e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 276.0 } } }, "qseis2025": { "relative_l2": 0.22951382655472283, "correlation": 0.9897023617946057, "peak_absolute_m": 4.032786470521637e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 4.718896012314888e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 276.0, "components": { "E": { "relative_l2": 0.23325738523935233, "correlation": 0.9912922196061632, "peak_absolute_m": 1.8688967424193267e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 1.982428249685609e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 256.0 }, "N": { "relative_l2": 0.23325738523935324, "correlation": 0.9912922196061632, "peak_absolute_m": 3.23702411197024e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 3.433666450815314e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 256.0 }, "U": { "relative_l2": 0.2233134153054795, "correlation": 0.9871619471661072, "peak_absolute_m": 4.032786470521637e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 4.718896012314888e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 276.0 } } }, "spgrn2012": { "relative_l2": 0.042577007797639316, "correlation": 0.9997632002002402, "peak_absolute_m": 4.905164303361373e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 4.718896012314888e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 278.0, "components": { "E": { "relative_l2": 0.04063015839734303, "correlation": 0.9998317382325957, "peak_absolute_m": 2.0603192713472928e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 1.982428249685609e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 258.0 }, "N": { "relative_l2": 0.04063015839734268, "correlation": 0.9998317382325961, "peak_absolute_m": 3.5685776577867993e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 3.433666450815314e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 258.0 }, "U": { "relative_l2": 0.04555591501977681, "correlation": 0.99963459504824, "peak_absolute_m": 4.905164303361373e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 4.718896012314888e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 278.0 } } }, "spgrn2020": { "relative_l2": 0.0, "correlation": 1.0, "peak_absolute_m": 4.718896012314888e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 4.718896012314888e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 278.0, "components": { "E": { "relative_l2": 0.0, "correlation": 0.9999999999999998, "peak_absolute_m": 1.982428249685609e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 1.982428249685609e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 258.0 }, "N": { "relative_l2": 0.0, "correlation": 1.0, "peak_absolute_m": 3.433666450815314e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 3.433666450815314e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 258.0 }, "U": { "relative_l2": 0.0, "correlation": 1.0, "peak_absolute_m": 4.718896012314888e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 4.718896012314888e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 278.0 } } }, "qssp2020": { "relative_l2": 0.014227506419163599, "correlation": 0.9998970732883025, "peak_absolute_m": 4.678830861541937e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 4.718896012314888e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 276.0, "components": { "E": { "relative_l2": 0.012327191548072639, "correlation": 0.9999172555832277, "peak_absolute_m": 1.9919005083462667e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 1.982428249685609e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 256.0 }, "N": { "relative_l2": 0.012327191548080155, "correlation": 0.9999172555832281, "peak_absolute_m": 3.450072884077899e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 3.433666450815314e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 256.0 }, "U": { "relative_l2": 0.01685841216426284, "correlation": 0.9998569590908136, "peak_absolute_m": 4.678830861541937e-09, "reference_peak_absolute_m": 4.718896012314888e-09, "absolute_peak_time_s": 276.0 } } } } } ], "checks": { "qseis06_vs_qseis2025": { "passed": true, "same_native_time_axes": true, "rtol": 1e-05, "atol_m": 1e-20, "scope": "all saved native displacement samples", "max_absolute_difference_m": 0.0 }, "qssp2020_vs_spgrn2020": { "passed": true, "relative_l2_limit": 0.05, "relative_l2_by_distance": [ 0.008892090245270245, 0.0037799442529229473, 0.014227506419163599 ] } }, "passed": true, "figures": [ "all-backends.png", "spherical-comparison.png", "qseis-comparison.png" ] }